Official Policy & Guidelines
Last Reviewed: November 2026
Reviewer Guidelines
Reviewer Guidelines & Best Practices
Peer review is the bedrock of scientific literature. We are profoundly grateful to our international reviewers who dedicate their expertise to upholding the rigor and validity of published research.
Core Review Criteria
When assessing a manuscript, reviewers should evaluate:
- Originality & Significance: Does the study present novel insights, validate contested findings, or advance existing paradigms in a meaningful way?
- Methodological Rigor: Are the experimental design, sample size, controls, and statistical tests scientifically sound and clearly explained?
- Data Interpretation: Are the author's conclusions fully supported by the presented data, without overreaching or speculative claims?
- Clarity & Structure: Is the manuscript well-organized and clearly written in intelligible English? Are figures and tables informative and legible?
- Ethical Standards: Are appropriate IRB approvals, animal welfare declarations, and conflict of interest statements provided?
Structure of a Constructive Reviewer Report
A high-quality review report contains:
- Brief Summary: A concise synopsis demonstrating your understanding of the study's objectives and main findings.
- Major Comments: Methodological flaws, missing controls, unsupported conclusions, or essential additional analyses required before publication.
- Minor Comments: Typographical errors, unclear phrasing, figure formatting suggestions, and citation improvements.
- Confidential Recommendation to Editor: Clear recommendation (Accept, Minor Revisions, Major Revisions, or Reject) with candid reasoning.
Confidentiality & Ethical Obligations
Manuscripts submitted for review are strictly privileged documents. Reviewers must not:
- Share, discuss, or quote unpublished manuscripts with colleagues or students.
- Use data, insights, or methodologies from unpublished papers in their own work.
- Input unpublished manuscript text into generative AI models or public online tools.
- Agree to review if a conflict of interest exists (e.g., recent co-authorship, institutional rivalry, financial stake).